Dining Greyladygourmet.com | 's Restaurant Review Guide  Island
Home Reviews Newsletter Contact
 Home > Reviews > Tuckernuck Inn Cafe      
What's Happening at the GLG?
2003 Full Restaurant Review - Tuckernuck Inn Cafe
Our Advertisers
T-ShirtWE NEED YOU!!! (To submit a review.) Simply fill out our online form after you have eaten at any restaurant to tell us what you think and you could be eligible for the Greyladygourmet T-Shirt.
Enter the 2003 T-Shirt Contest!!! >>

Top Restaurant Picks from the Archive
2002

What You Think...
We are unbiased and anonymous reviewers.  But what do you think about restaurants? Others share their reviews of dining experiences.
Read More >>

Greyladygourmet Email Newsletter
READ ALL ABOUT IT!!! (GLG Newsletter, that is...) Do you want to keep up with the latest dining news on ? Sign-up for our free seasonal newsletter and we will keep you informed.
GLG Email Sign-Up >>

Feedback
Do you like our site? Agree with our reviews? (Or strongly disagree?) We want to hear what you think. We strive to make this a better service.         
Feedback >>
 
Tuckernuck Inn CafeIntro
This Restaurant/Inn has been around for 20 years, and changes owners or chefs every few years. This year a new chef, Richard Preston "Dickie" is at the helm. Minor changes are noted in the dining room's decor but the big change this year is in the prices which have dropped dramatically reflecting a different approach to the culinary offerings. The food is good, but average. This is an interesting dining option for patrons who are looking for a simple evening out at bargain prices for .

Ambience3 Star
Tucked off of busy Union Street, this restaurant has a parking lot provided for overnight and dining patrons, a real boon to the frenzied parking place hunter in town. Protected by a high privet hedge, there is a delightful patio filled with red checkered table cloths and candle lit lanterns for those having drinks, dining, or simply waiting for a table. The window boxes overflow with flowers which adds to the welcoming atmosphere. The interior decor repeats the red checked table cloths and lanterns. Attactive white lattice work separates two booths overlooking the patio and a third booth as well as tables for two and four complete the bistro setting. This is a fine place for warm nights with a choice of the cool breezes on the patio or the air conditioning with soft overhead fans of the main dining room.

Food2.5 Star
What we noticed first were the prices, considerably lower than in previous years and a bargain for restaurants. The menu also reflected a more traditional dining selection. Creamed lobster in a pie, pan roasted chicken, shrimp and vegetable quesadilla, paper bagged fish, baked flounder with crabmeat stuffing, the night's preparation of pasta and grilled petit filet are standard fare with daily variations on the fish and chicken. New England clam chowder, a second homemade soup, and three Tuckernuck Inn Cafesalads are offered. In the appetizer section, a baked crab dip, "Portuguese" style clams are offered nightly, along with the chef's nightly choices such as chicken liver pate and oriental ginger lamb bites, or scallop serviche.

The seafood bisque was very good, filled with chunks of fish, scallops and shrimp. The small salad, with Boston lettuce, stilton cheese, cranberries and pecans was adequate, but needed a more interesting dressing. Salmon was the fish in the paper bagged catch, a healthy choice, combined with fresh steamed vegetables, but rather bland. The cod, shrimp, and scallop fish cakes were well packed with fish, not fillers, but somewhat overpowered by the rich red pepper roville and heavy sauce surrounding the cakes. For dessert we sampled lemon curd tart and mango tart, both identical in appearance, but appropriately flavored and average.


Other Observations
The hostess and one waitress covered the entire dining room which was not full on this summer evening in July. Our waitress informed us that the rolls were warming, but they never made it to our table. When a knife was cleared with the salad, a replacement never arrived. She did ask us how the dinner was, but we were curious to see if she noticed the lapses, without our comments. When we were prepared to order dessert, the server was on the patio folding table cloths and storing the lanterns. We were in no rush, and she was pleasant, but the approach reflects the new, casual, atmosphere of Tuckernuck Inn Cafe.

Our overall impression was that this restaurant is changing its stripe, appealing to a different crowd than in previous years. Although prices are moderate, there is nothing on the menu to satisfy families with youngsters. The musical background is from the forties and our guess is the goal is to attract a senior set. There clearly is a need for this and we wish them well. Try it and let us know your thoughts.

Our Rating

Ambiance
3 Star

Food
2.5 Star
Service
2.5 Star
Price
$$
How we rate the restaurants >>
  Directions
Tel: (508) 228-3886 60 Union St. , MA 02554
See the 2002 Review > >

Island of Nantucket
 Nantucket Wedding Video
DininginMass.com
WheretheFigawi.com
Want to Advertise Here?
     
  HOME | RESTAURANT REVIEWS | NEWSLETTER | CONTACT|
 
 
 
  Copyright © 2001-2004 Greyladygourmet.com. All Rights Reserved.  
  Site built & maintained by WildmanProduction.com  
     
  Banner