Dining Greyladygourmet.com | Nantucket's Restaurant Review Guide Nantucket Island
Home Reviews Newsletter Contact
 Home > Reviews > Boarding House      
What's Happening at the GLG?
Welcome Back!!! (June 2003)
Our Advertisers
T-ShirtWE NEED YOU!!! (To submit a review.) Simply fill out our online form after you have eaten at any Nantucket restaurant to tell us what you think and you could be eligible for the Greyladygourmet T-Shirt.
Enter the 2003 T-Shirt Contest!!! >>

Top Restaurant Picks from the Archive
2002

What You Think...
We are unbiased and anonymous reviewers.  But what do you think about Nantucket restaurants? Others share their reviews of dining experiences.
Read More >>

Greyladygourmet Email Newsletter
READ ALL ABOUT IT!!! (GLG Newsletter, that is...) Do you want to keep up with the latest dining news on Nantucket? Sign-up for our free seasonal newsletter and we will keep you informed.
GLG Email Sign-Up >>

Feedback
Do you like our site? Agree with our reviews? (Or strongly disagree?) We want to hear what you think. We strive to make this a better service.         
Feedback >>
 
Boarding HouseIntro
The Boarding House, renovated two years ago, is centrally located on busy Federal Street. Tourists walking by can't help but notice the patio with scattered tables outside of the popular bar at the entrance, and the below street level windows which look into the appealing dining room. This restaurant is owned and run in companionship with The Pearl, the more sophisticated, modern styled restaurant housed above in the same building. In a unique partnership, both are overseen by the same executive chef, Robert Nelson, yet offer different menus. The atmosphere at the Boarding House is cosy and grotto like with muted earth tones. The food is consistently excellent and the service top notch. This restaurant is ideal for groups of twos and fours and is best when not full, since conversation can be difficult; with its fine reputation, however, you are much more likely to be dining at a full house.

Ambiance
Entrance is through the popular and often crowded bar where a few tables nestle along the wall; but make a reservation for the dining room if you wish to hear anything but the bar crowd. Patrons of the past may miss the famed asparagus mural at the end of the small dining room, but it has been replaced by an attractive screened cabinet of wines. Three tables for two are placed there at the far end. The rest of the room is arranged with tables for twos and fours on either side. Two tables toward the front can accomodate larger groups. The 2001 renovation eliminated tables that crowded the center of the restaurant and, from the point of ease of service and noise level, is a welcome change.
Rough surfaced walls are bathed in soft hidden lights, arching up the curved ceiling. Earth tones create a warm atmosphere. There are a few pictures about the room, an interesting large lamp and a few wine bottles on a ledge at the room's far end, but these are hardly noticeable. The general effect is soothing and intimate. The safari aprons on the wait staff, who are dressed in black slacks and tops, add an interesting contrast. The service is outstanding, courteous, efficient and helpful.
Boarding House

Food
The current rage on is an overwhelmlng selection of hors d'hoeuves, many of which approximate half the price of the entree. The Boarding House follows this pattern offering not only the traditional soup of the day and choice of salads, but such choices as Black Angus Carpacci, Wellfleet little neck clams, duck breast, sea scallops, and foie gras, each specially designed with the chef's touch. The evening entrees included two beef choices (marinated black angus sirloin or beef tenderloin), four seafood selections (sushi yellowfin tuna, soft shell crab, Atlantic salmon, twin lobster tails), and two traditional choices of grilled leg of lamb or chicken.
We selected the soft shelled crab tempura, served in a smoked bacon emulsion, with tomato concasse and preserved lemon and the sauteed Atlantic salmon served with a stuffed tomato with a cranberry ragout, ancho chili with basil sauce. Both arrived very attractively prepared. Soft shelled crab is a favorite dish with this patron but the tempura preparation, intended to add interest, obscured the flavor of the crab which was somewhat disappointing. The small piece of salmon arrived with a tomato sliced at the top and filled with the ragout. For those who like fish a little rare, this was perfect, but for this diner, a few more minutes of sauteeing would have added to the the enjoyment. The ragout, was a bit heavy on beans, and the spicey addition of cranberry was unnoticed.
Dessert included a dish of assorted sorbets and a caramelised apple tart. The sorbet was average, without any particular creative addition, but the carmel gave the apple dessert a chewy tang that set it apart from traditional apple desserts.

Other Observations:
We usually opt to come to this appealing place on the shoulder seasons and Memorial Day weekend was perfect. The restaurant was only half full and we could relax and visit without the noise which has proved troublesome in the past. Our waitress was delightful and we especially enjoyed her description of the wine festival held the previous week. When we later ordered a glass of Russian River chardonnay, she seemed certain that it was not available, but graciously apologized on returning with the menu having confused the current listing with the previous week's selections. No one likes to make mistakes but we were impressed by her willingness to admit she was wrong and apologize. How rare that is in our world today!

Our Rating

Ambiance
4 Star

Food
4 Star
Service
5 Star
Price
$$$
Boarding House Web Site
Tel: 508-228-9622 12 Federal St.

 

2002 Review >>
2001 Review >>

Island of Nantucket
Nantucket Wedding Video
Crabs-N-Lobster
Soccer Cleats
DininginMass.com
WheretheFigawi.com
Want to Advertise Here?
     
  HOME | NANTUCKET RESTAURANT REVIEWS | NEWSLETTER | CONTACT|
 
 
 
  Copyright © 2001-2004 Greyladygourmet.com. All Rights Reserved.  
  Site built & maintained by WildmanProduction.com