Fine Dining Reviews ACK
Home Reviews Newsletter Contact
 Home > Reviews > Company of the Caldron 2002
Search Our Reviews
Full Restaurant Review - 2002
Advertisers
Alphabetically
By Food Rating
By Price
Contest Winner

Tim F.
See our T-shirt contest winner on Greyladygourmet.com.
Our Top Picks
2002
ORAN MOR
2001
THE PEARL
 
Company of the Caldron - 5 India St., , MA 02554 (508) 228-4016

Intro
A small red one-story building with vines cascading over the windows is the home of Company of the Cauldron. Romance and charm abound in a room filled with candles flickering over seafaring treasures and paintings hanging on the ceilings and walls. A fixed menu, which changes each day, is posted outside the door and a week in advance on their website. The excellent offerings are prepared in the small kitchen at the rear of the dining room by All and Andrea, chefs in the third year here. Only wine is available either by half or full bottle. There are sittings at 7 and 9 PM and the experience of having all the diners arrive at the same time is handled adeptly by the skilled wait staff, creating a festive atmosphere unique on .

Ambiance
We have enjoyed the Company of the Caldron for years but had not reviewed this restaurant until our visit this summer. Seated next to the wonderful display of fresh flowers nestled in the baker's rack, our table was perfect for an intimate dinner for two. Flowered tableclothes with a flickering candle, warm bread and wine set the tone. The room is filled with objects of interest: a life preserver hung above the wooden booth next to one of the front windows, the huge half ship hanging from the ceiling, sconces and candelabrum with candles, brass pots on the walls and a number of paintings. The huge wine rack and open entrance to the small kitchen create a world apart from the street outside. When the harpist began strumming, the atmosphere was complete.

Food
The appetizer of the evening was a crab cake with sorel sauce, accompanied with pan seared greens and sweet pepper confetti. If there had been nothing else on the menu we would have gone home in ecstacy. This creation of wonderful lumps of crab is better than any in memory! The green salad with a light roquefort dressing was the perfect follow up to the first course. A spectacular piece of baked swordfish arrived with a ragout of vegetables and mashed potatoes. Fish markets do not sell such thick chunk-like portions and the presentation was stunning. The fish was moist and delicately flavored with every mouthful savored. The dessert was the chef's idea of mixing interesting textures and tastes, a chocolate gelato, appricots and a very hard biscotta. The adventurous goal was achieved, but one of the great desserts offered other evenings might have been preferred.

Other Observations:
This is the third season for the two chefs, All and Andrea, and they clearly are masters with the planning, preparing, and presentation of the evening's meal. The wait staff are adapt at handling the arrival of guests, serving courses and wine and answering our questions. The restaurant is closed on Mondays. This summer we recommend looking over the menu for a favorite entree and making a reservation for that evening; you won't be disappointed.

Our Rating

Ambiance

Food
Service
Price
$$$
How we rate the restaurants >>

Company of the Caldron Web Site When is this Restaurant
Closed for the Season?

Directions

 

 


Island of Nantucket
Nantucket Wedding Video

DiningInMass.com

NantucketWeddingVideo

Want to Advertise Here?

Newsletter
Submit Your Company of the Caldron Review
The Archive
We'll keep you informed on our latest dining reviews. Seasonal email newsletter here!
Newsletter >>
Have you wined and dined at this restaurant before? Care to share your opinion or perhaps beg to differ with our own? Post your review online right now.
 Post Your Reviews >>
Need a second opinion? Check out last year's
reviews and view our consumer reviews.

Boarding House 2001 Review >>
View Consumer Reviews >>
     
 
       
  HOME | NANTUCKET RESTAURANT REVIEWS | NEWSLETTER | CONTACT|    
 
   
  Copyright © 2001-2004 Greyladygourmet.com. All Rights Reserved.    
  Site built & maintained by WildmanProduction.com