The Dining Experts Greyladygourmet - 's Restaurant Review Guide ACK
Home Reviews Newsletter Contact
 Home > Reviews > Consumer Reviews
Search Our Reviews
Restaurant Reviews - Consumer Reviews
Our Advertisers
By Food Rating
By Price
Contest
See our T-shirt contest winner on Greyladygourmet.com.
Greyladygourmet Newsletter
We'll keep you informed on our latest dining reviews. Seasonal email newsletter here!
Newsletter >>
2001, 2002 & 2003 Reviews
Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
21 Federal St. (Memorial Weekend 2004) 4.0 Star 4.0 Star 4.0 Star
by Lisa S.
I was very pleased with my experience at 21 Federal. The most dissapointing aspect of the meal was the less than average bread assortment provided with dinner; however, my dinner more than made up for it with a surprisingly tastey halibut over pureed cauliflower and cabbage. Dessert was not terribly exciting (ours was a chocolate mouse on sweet cookies); yet, everyone else at the table seemed to be very pleased with their picks. The "variations on cream" looked inviting! Our wine was superb and the service was promt and consistent.
Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
Yoshi's Sushi (Memorial Weekend 2004) 1.5 Star 4.0 Star 5.0 Star
by Lisa S.
Not recommended for in restaurant dining; but certainly for take-out and a "sushi at sunset" excursion!

Yoshi's has high quality sushi which has failed to dissapoint us yet. Always an impressive display, and a wide variety of options. Sushi at Yoshi's tends to be slightly smaller and more tightly wrapped than some restaurants in Boston; but, is just as fresh and flavorful.

Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
21 Federal St. (Memorial Weekend 2004) 3.5 Star 4.0 Star 4.0 Star
by Craig S.
The food was simply exquisite. I had a 1/2 lobster with braised beef entree. The beef was "like butter" and could not have tasted any better. For an appetizer I ordered an asparagus soup. I light cream base which didn't overwhelm and allowed a flavorful asparagus to treat the taste buds and set the tone for the main course. My only criticism would be the accompanying vegetable medley and mashed potatoes could have been more generous - but they were both seasoned to perfection...

Onto dessert. I ordered their Boston cream pie bread pudding. A decadently delicious way to end a memorable meal. Highly recommend it...

Other info ... As for the 3.5 star ambiance rating, we were seated downstairs. Not quite as intimate or inviting as the upstairs appeared to be.

Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
Amelia's (Early September 2003)
4.5 Star 4.5 Star 4.5 Star
by Steve L.
AMELIA'S -- Living in Manhattan my wife and I frequent all manners of restaurants. Amelia's not only delivered one of the best meals that I have ever had, the attention to detail is of the sort that you rarely find today in our "fast-food" nation. The Host handles the guests beautifully and was very capable with the wine list. Our servers were also very professional and friendly -- without being overly so. They knew the menu and knew when to ask questions of the kitchen staff and us. Overall a great dining experience. One which I'll be repeating within two weeks, upon my next visit to the island.
Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
Henry's (Mid-July 2003) 3.5 Star 4 Star 4 Star
by John B.
Don't care what else comes and goes, my family loves Henry's. It's been there since I was a kid, and now MY kids crave it as much as my wife and I do (one of our first dates was going to Surfside with sandwiches from Henry's). Same as it's always been, with more and more improvements. A good thing that just keeps getting better.
Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
Oran Mor (Early July 2003) 3.5 Star 3.5 Star 4 Star
by John C.
Having made reservations nearly two weeks in advance, I had pretty much assumed I'd be getting a respectable table. However, upon my arrival, the hostess showed me a table adjacent to the bar and next to a group of people waiting for tables around the hostess desk. I asked her if she had another table, and she accomodated us with a much better option in one of the back dining rooms (which are quite nice, and unique) after a reasonable 15 minute wait. But, if one is making a reservation at Oran Mor, they should request that they not be in the bar - the atmosphere between the bar area and dining room are worlds apart, and the bar is simply an unacceptable dining environment at these prices. The restaurant should make it a point to mention these two distinct table locations, and not assume that the bar is OK.
Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
Provisions (at the Hy-Line Wharf, April 2003) 3STar 4Star 5Star
by Anonymous
This is a casual cafe located right at the Wharf. The sandwiches, made with your choice of fresh bread, are fantastic! Large, extremely fresh ingredients, and interesting combinations. I also tried one of their homemade brownies which was really, really good. The prices here are extremely reasonable. You may eat in or take out. I rate this place EXCELLENT.
Restaurant   Your Website:  
Toppers/Chanticleer (Received March 2003)    
by William A.
Toppers a tie with the Chanticleer, you guys must be smoking some type of good seaweed, the Chanticleer is the greatest, there is no other.
Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
21 Federal (Received November 2002)
by MIKEL B.
I am Mikel from the Basque Country (Spain, not really), I worked in your restaurant 7 years ago. I was with Borja who worked in repostery. I remember Steve, Jean Pierre, Eanel and Wayne (Dish-Washers), Johana, Taira... I had a really good time with you. See you soon.
Regards, Mikel
Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
Cioppino's (Mid October 2002)
by Jason K.
A fine all around dining experience! Extensive and well rounded wine list compliments a variety of dishes well suited for even the most veteran of diners. A fabulous choice in the heart of downtown . My wife and I recommend it highly!
Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
Arno's (Mid October 2002)
by Jason K.
This review highlights breakfast at "Arno's at 41 Main Street" which is seemingly a very popular breakfast site. Arno's offers breakfast until 2pm for late risers and fills up quickly. The food selection is quite good for breakfast but perhaps what separates this restaurant from others is the quality of food (breakfast) for the price! A great place to start your shopping day located on Main Street downtown .
Restaurant
Ambiance
Service
Food
The Brotherhood (Mid October 2002)
by Jason K.
This review is for "The Brotherhood" restaurant located just down the street from the Jared Coffin House and across from Cioppino's. If your looking for low-key, quick fare this is perhaps one of the few places to grab a burger or other simple fare from a limited (but quite good) sandwich oriented menu. The dark below street level atmosphere adds to the mystique of "The Brotherhood" and before long you're convinced that your a clandestine member. Be sure to view the flip side of their menu as it displays a world class selection of cordials, imported liquors, cognacs and after dinner type drinks.
Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
Oran Mor (Late September 2002)
by Bill W.
While Oran Mor appears to be a top ranking on Greylady Gourmet, we found our dining experience to be less than five star.

For our engagement dinner on , we chose Oran Mor and alerted the restaurant staff of our special day. We arrived in tandem with three other couples at six o'clock and
the wait staff seemed rather disorganized and the host was not ready to take us to our tables. The setting is an upstairs area of two rooms and a bar and was very quaint.

The waitress was generally nice, but also seemed hurried due to the increased crowd. She was polite and made a suggestion on the beer. However, she did drop a spoon in my water while setting the silverware for an appetizer. The waitress did not pick up that it was our special day nor did we appear to be seated at a special table as promised.

The food was above average. The bread was not warm and sort of tough. The mussel appetizer had little baby crabs in the shells which was unexpected. The menus mentioned something about crab meat, but I did not remember a mention of actual baby crabs in the mussels. The only fish selection on the menu was tuna, which I opted for medium cooked as opposed to the traditional rare. The tuna was fine, but the mashed potatoes were lumpy and stringy with a consistency of squash. Dessert shared with a coffee and chocolate cake were a pleasant ending. The waitress did finally congratulate us as we signed the check, but who couldn't notice our hands dangling her ring by the candlelight?

Overall the experience was nice, but not quite as memorable as we had hoped.
Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
The Summer House (Late August 2002)
by Tim F.
What could be better than a gorgeous day on ACK and a wonderful outside setting by the ocean to help you enjoy it. For one thing, the best Fish-n-Chips this side of the "pond". This is no joke, the batter was light and the fish had GREAT flavor. Add to that amazing fries (all washed down with a few Whale's Tale Ale -- of course) and you've got yourself the PERFECT lunch. So don't delay, jump on your bike the next time your "on island" and enjoy, you wont be sorry!!!
Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
The snACK shack (Late August 2002)
by Tim F.
It's slightly off the beaten track, but well worth the adventure. A recent visit to the snACK shack proved there's always room for another sandwhich shop on island.  Although they provide a wide array of house specialties, they were more than happy to handle my special order (including the fresh avacados) and cold Nectars to quench my thirst. This was the place for me!  My wife mentioned that it also doesn't hurt that the "hunks" behind the counter were reason enough to return again and again.
Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
Ship's Inn (Mid October 2001)
by Heather K.
We were celebrating a very important event (my husband's 30th birthday!!) and the restaurant was wonderful to us!! They gave us a beautiful table in the corner and we were told it was "ours for the night", which relaxed us from the start. The service was exceptional and the food was phenomenal!!! They even included a candle on our souffle, (which you HAVE to order if you dine here!!) and sang "Happy Birthday". Also, the restaurant was nice and quiet, so it was very easy to hold a conversation. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone visiting the island. You will pay, but it is worth it!!!
Restaurant Ambiance Service Food
Ship's Inn (Mid October 2001)
by Jason K.
This restaurant exhibited a superior ability to make a special event (Birthday) that much more special. The cozy nautical environment was both romantic and relaxing, but the real attribute that stands out is their level of service delivered to their customers.

 


Island of Nantucket
Nantucket Wedding Video

DiningInMass.com

WheretheFigawi?

Want to Advertise Here?

 

     
  Banner
       
  HOME | RESTAURANT REVIEWS | NEWSLETTER | CONTACT    
 
   
  Copyright © 2001-2004 Greyladygourmet.com. All Rights Reserved.    
  Site built & maintained by WildmanProduction.com